Monday, 29 January 2007

Vista & Office 2007 First Impressions

Those with even a passing interest in things IT can’t have failed to notice that Vista has at last been released into the big, bad world – it’s been long enough coming. Finally I received the entire 2007 suite in my Action Pack last week and decided to have a go at testing it. So here are my first thoughts.

I’m running the software on a laptop (bought specifically to test the software). Specification is: Core 2 duo processor running at 2GHz (64 bit), 2Gig RAM, embedded Intel graphics chip 945GM with 256M RAM. The Vista scoring was generally 4.5 to 5 with a 3 being given to the graphics system. So plenty of memory and grunt, but a medium graphics system, just as expected.

The installation of Vista was quite painless, this was an upgrade from XP SP2 and I blew out the XP install to give Vista a chance to start from scratch. Unlike XP, Vista requires authentication with Microsoft or it will cease to operate after (I think) 60 days. No chance of overloading licences here. My first impression was that it was very ‘pretty’ compared to XP, in the same way XP was prettier than W2000. My graphics system is powerful enough to run the Aero Glass interface and it does look good. There’s a nifty side-bar where useful system apps can be loaded – such as resource meters, address books, photo albums.

The bad news is that everything has moved! As an IT consultant I’m use to being able to grab a computer and work with command prompts, the ever-so-useful Start\Run has gone! Ok, playing around you can type ‘Command’ in at the search bar and it loads. Then the biggest pain makes itself apparent, everything you do that affects the system throws a prompt up asking if you’re really sure, even for administration accounts. Useful commands like ‘ipconfig/renew’ don’t work! There must be a way around it, on Unix it would be ‘su root’ I’m sure there is a Microsoft equivalent – further investigation is needed. A side effect of the compulsory authentication requirements is a total downer, if like most IT managers you build a standard desktop and roll it out to every PC on your network then you’re now forced to go down the route of an Open or Select agreement with Microsoft, no more Ghost images without it. As an aside, what on earth possessed Microsoft to not include Telnet as part of the standard build? It has to be installed as a separate component and I had to Google for the answer.

My biggest problem with Vista is that users are going to hate that changes and keep calling on IT support for help. On the other hand this is an opportunity for IT support to provide this help, it’s going to be expensive. Basic user training is going to be a must while the rollout takes place.

Many consultants (including me) are saying wait until Service Pack 1 before switching, Microsoft state there are good technical reasons to start the switch from day 1. Personally I’d wait. The biggest drawback to the switch is likely to be the hardware required to run the beast on. It’s very hardware intensive. Initially the OS itself uses around 800M of memory, I’d usually recommend around 512 with XP as the operating system including office type applications (office, browsing etc), I think with Vista a similar recommendation is going to be 2G with a minimum of 1G for very light users – fortunately memory is cheap these days, and already memory prices are falling as production is ramping up. Having the twin processors in my laptop, I am usually hitting 50% usage for office type applications, this would seem to indicate that most modern processors will run Vista so long as you’re not doing games or graphics work. The lower end graphics system on the laptop runs the Aero Glass interface quite well which is good.

On the down side, I’m waiting for device drivers to be released for some of my network devices, the Bluetooth dongle doesn’t work and neither does my Nokia phone software, this isn’t so good seeing as hardware vendors have had a year to prepare for this (both are expected around April). Worse is my Netgear stuff, looking on the support forums there is a lot of moaning that network cards don’t have device drivers working. For me the biggest issue is that my Network Attached Storage (NAS) server doesn’t work anymore and there is no indication when it will be working, thus I have lost my 1TB main file store. There really is no excuse for this and Netgear has lost a lot of street-cred by not having drivers ready for their NAS devices.

On the whole then it’s been quite a pleasant surprise, although whether this will carry on once end users get a hold of the new systems is an entirely different question. There’s still a lot of exploring and learning to do before your IT staff will feel comfortable supporting Vista, and they’ll be taking all the learning courses and tests from Microsoft, so don’t expect seamless support from day 1.

At the same time as I installed Vista, I also put the new versions of Office on to see how that looked and worked. If Vista is a change, Office is a shocker. The new ‘ribbon’ which changes constantly depending on what you’re doing is, frankly, horrible. It can be turned off which I’m sure is how most frequent users will have it configured.

The biggest issues from a support perspective is likely to be the simple stuff “How do I open a document?”, “How do I do a save-as so Word 2000 users can read it?”. The more complex stuff like mail-merging is a dream to use, it’s the basic stuff that has moved into places beyond recognition (or it might be just me), I liked the old File menu. Once you turn off the Ribbon the interface is very clean which I approve of and makes for more screen real-estate for actually working on the document.

The new look of the user interface fits in very well with the clean look of Vista and it’s obvious the two were designed together, as was Internet Explorer 7, this has the same kind of look and feel – and again in IE7 it’s the simple stuff which is hard to find.

“How do I search the web page for a specific word?”

Answer: “change to Firefox!”.

Good things about Office 2007 is the close integration with Groove and SharePoint Services, I can see this being of great benefit to everyone in any field, whether in the voluntary sector or commercial. This integration could well become the driving reason to upgrade to Office 2007. I’d give it a few months to settle down before launching into an upgrade programme, but it’s something I’m already working on with a couple of my clients. For those who are not familiar with these services, Groove is a peer-peer document sharing and collaboration system while SharePoint is an information management system which can provide secure access to information both within and without an organization (intranet and extranet).

Rounding up then, Vista looks good, but is a memory hungry beast and needs a half decent graphics system to run the Aero Glass interface, look to rollout as you purchase new machines over the next three years (unless anything pressing happens to force an upgrade), don’t expect top-quality, immediate support from your IT resource for a few months, maybe start looking in 9 months to a year when SP1 is expected to be released.

Office 2007 looks good, and the new interface is very clean. There may be reasons to perform an upgrade now if you want/need to take advantage of the close integration with Groove and SharePoint. Don’t try and go this alone without IT support, these are not trivial services to implement on an ad-hoc basis.

Good luck everyone

Martin

No comments: